Publication: Reassuring humoral and cellular immune responses to SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in participants with systemic sclerosis

Benoit JM, Breznik JA, Huynh A, Cowbrough B, Baker B, Heessels L, Lodhi S, Yan E, Bhakta H, Clare R, Nazy I, Bramson JL, Larché MJ, Bowdish DM. Reassuring humoral and cellular immune responses to SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in participants with systemic sclerosis. Immunol Lett. 2024 Sep 19;270:106929. doi: 10.1016/j.imlet.2024.106929. 

Below is a Bluesky thread that summarizes and explains our manuscript. Click here to read it on Bluesky.

New publication alert! “Reassuring humoral and cellular immune responses to SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in participants with systemic sclerosis” Read on to learn why we did this study and why it is important. 1/n https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0165247824001032?via%3Dihub

https://bsky.app/profile/msmacrophage.bsky.social/post/3l5zdipjxwe2o

Systemic Sclerosis(SSc) is a rare autoimmune disorder that causes fibrosis of the organs. Because it is caused an immune system gone awry, patients and their doctors were concerned that their immune systems might not respond to the vaccine and leave them less protected 2/n

Because SSC is an autoimmune condition, people generally take immunosuppressive drugs, which can also lead to lower vaccine responses and higher risk of infection. We investigated whether antibody or T cell responses to vaccination were affected in SSC. 3/n

Good news! People with SSC made the same amount of antibodies to the receptor binding domain of the Spike protein (i.e, the bit of the virus that the virus uses to get into us) after their second, third, and fourth SARS-CoV-2 vaccinations. 4/n

More good news! T cell responses to vaccines are thought to help with severe disease and may offer some cross-variant protection. Following the second, third, and fourth SARS-CoV-2 vaccinations, participants with SSc had T cell responses = those without SSC. 5/n

For the immunology geeks: People living with SSc have elevated levels of serum cytokines associated with T cell differentiation. Could this change Th1/2/17/reg mix posts vaccination? Nope. 6/n

Caveat#1: This is a small study (because a rare disease) and we couldn’t investigate all the different drugs that people are on. For more info on how drugs affect vaccination responses see our other studies 7/n https://acrjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/acr2.11697

Caveat #2: This is very much a comparison of the quantity of immune responses, not the quality. There could still be qualitative differences in immune responses that we didn’t catch but… 8/n

…even though there is very little data on whether SSC is associated with higher infection risk or poorer outcomes what little exists doesn’t find a massive difference compared to the general population 9/n https://acrjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/acr.25226

Take home message #1: Participants with SSc mount similar responses to SARS-CoV-2 vaccination as controls who do not have autoimmune conditions. 10/n

Take home message #2: Many ppl with autoimmune conditions are afraid that vaccination is unsafe for them because they know their immune system is a bit wonky. It is not the disease that affects immune responses, rather it’s some, not all, drugs at some, not all, doses. 11/n

Thanks to emerging leader & 1st author Jenna Benoit (graduating & looking for a job next year – hint), rheumatologist extraordinaire, Dr. Maggie Larche, cellular immunologist Dr. J. Breznik & J Bramson, team Antibody (Nazy, Huynh) & with special thanks to…..12/n

….our participants. People with SSC often have skin changes which makes blood draws especially hard. Thank you for your commitment to our study and huge props to our exceptional phlebotomist/RC Braeden Cowbrough – our unsung hero. 13/n Fin.

Publication: “Monocyte-driven inflamm-aging reduces intestinal barrier function in females”

Click here to access: Monocyte-driven inflamm-aging reduces intestinal barrier function in females published in Immunity and Ageing, September 2024.

This publication by former PDF, Dr Candice Quin and team, discovers that inflammatory markers and gut permeability increase with age, but the leaky gut seems to be a female specific phenomena in both mice and humans.

Bluesky explainer thread below and here https://bsky.app/profile/msmacrophage.bsky.social/post/3l5ethyexgp2u

New publication alert! “Monocyte-driven inflamm-aging reduces
intestinal barrier function in females” by lead author Dr Candice Quin @uniofaberdeen.bsky.social. Read on for some surprising insights into sex differences in aging, the microbiome, inflammation, and the ‘leaky gut’ hypothesis….1/n

With age levels of inflammatory mediators (cytokines, CRP, & others) increase in the blood and tissues. This is often called ‘inflamm-aging’, and higher than age-average levels of these mediators are associated with chronic disease, frailty, and other age-associated ills. 2/n

Men & women age differently (‘men die quicker, women live sicker’)so it stands to reason they might ‘inflam-age’ differently, but very few studies on aging investigate sex differences in the aging trajectory. We looked at cellular & soluble inflammatory markers and saw sex differences! 3/n

We were surprised by the magnitude of sex differences but immunology is literally one of the worst disciplines when it comes to reporting by sex https://elifesciences.org/articles/70817
By why do we ‘inflamm-age’ in the first place? Might the mechanisms of inflamm-aging differ by sex 4/n

One of the major theories is that with age a dysbiotic microbiota causes the gut to become leaky (alternatively, the gut gets leaky with age and this alters the microbiota). Bacterial products leak out and cause inflammation. We’ve published in mice, others in other model organisms 5/n https://www.cell.com/cell-host-microbe/fulltext/S1931-3128(17)30112-9?elsca1=etoc&elsca2=email&elsca3=1931-3128_20170412_21_4_&elsca4=Cell%20Press

Evidence for the ‘leaky gut’ hypothesis is weak in healthy humans (despite what the probiotic industry might say). Leakiness is generally found in people who have comorbidities, or are frail so we looked at healthy/non-frail male (41) females (54) btw 20-102 yrs and were surprised to find…6/n

…that women appeared to have leakier guts over the life course (as measured by the serum marker zonulin- imperfect), and only women had evidence of an age-associated increase in the bacterial product LPS in their serum. Could the leaky gut hypothesis be female specific? 7/n

Human studies are observational so we turned to mice to understand the chain of causality. Old female, but not male, mice did indeed have leakier guts and this seemed to be caused by TNF produced by the elevated number of circulating inflammatory monocytes. 8/n

Tl;dr The age-related leaky gut -> increased circulating bacterial products -> systemic inflammation hypothesis may only be true in females! (also – always investigate sex in your research) 9/n

Why? Well the female gut changes dramatically during pregnancy to increase nutrient absorption – perhaps that is why women seem to have more permeability over the life-course. We are doing some cool ongoing studies in vitro looking at male vs female monocytes ability to break the gut barrier. 10/n

Caveats: This was a non-frail, mostly white population – aging & immunology studies show tremendous differences by location so needs to be reproduced. Gut permeability measures were done by looking at serum markers – easy on the participant but indirect at best. 11/n

Thanks to the whole (unfortunately not on Bluesky team)! This was an incredibly fun and challenging project to work on but has cemented my commitment to considering sex in all the research we do. 👩‍🔬🧪🦠🚨 12/12

Publication: Chronic TNF in the aging microenvironment exacerbates Tet2 lost-of-function myeloid expansion

Download PDF here.

Link to journal here.

Abstract: Somatic mutations in the TET2 gene occur more frequently with age, imparting an intrinsic hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) advantage and contributing to a phenomenon termed clonal hematopoiesis of indeterminate potential (CHIP). Individuals with TET2-mutant CHIP have a higher risk of developing myeloid neoplasms and other aging-related conditions. Despite its role in unhealthy aging, the extrinsic mechanisms driving TET2-mutant CHIP clonal expansion remain unclear. We previously showed an environment containing tumor necrosis factor (TNF) favors TET2-mutant HSC expansion in vitro. We therefore postulated that age-related increases in TNF also provide an advantage to HSCs with TET2 mutations in vivo. To test this hypothesis, we generated mixed bone marrow chimeric mice of old wild-type (WT) and TNF–/– genotypes reconstituted with WT CD45.1+ and Tet2–/– CD45.2+ HSCs. We show that age-associated increases in TNF dramatically increased the expansion
of Tet2–/– cells in old WT recipient mice, with strong skewing toward the myeloid lineage. This aberrant myelomonocytic advantage was mitigated in old TNF–/– recipient mice, suggesting that TNF signaling is essential for the expansion Tet2-mutant myeloid clones. Examination of human patients with rheumatoid arthritis with clonal hematopoiesis revealed that hematopoietic cells carrying certain mutations, including in TET2, may be sensitive to reduced TNF bioactivity following blockade with adalimumab. This suggests that targeting TNF may reduce the burden of some forms of CHIP. To our knowledge, this is the first evidence to demonstrate that TNF has a causal role in driving TET2-mutant CHIP in vivo. These findings highlight TNF as a candidate therapeutic target to control TET2-mutant CHIP.

Bluesky explainer thread here:
New Paper Alert: “Chronic TNF in the aging microenvironment exacerbates Tet2 lost-of-function myeloid expansion” published in Blood Advances #ImmunoSky #CHIP https://authors.elsevier.com/sd/article/S2473952924003860 (1/n)

Over time the progenitor cells (#stemcells) in our bone marrow acquire random mutations, with some genes being more likely to acquire these mutations than other. The Tet2 gene is one that acquires mutations. This is a problem because it regulates other genes through methylation (2/n)

Hematopoetic #stemcells with Tet2 mutations favour production of myeloid cells (#neutrophils #monocytes) over lymphoid cells (#Tcells #Bcells) and can outcompete stem cells that don’t have Tet2 mutations.(3/n)

If too many white blood cells originate from these mutants it is called Clonal Hematopoesis of Indeterminate Potential or #CHIP. CHIP is associated with an increase in mortality, and pneumonia (see prev paper), because immune cells with these mutations don’t work as well (4/n) https://shorturl.at/JNk6d

With age the proportion of Tet2 mutant cells increases and it is thought that the increased #inflammation that occurs with age contributes. Darwinian evolution happens in the bone marrow and stem cells with Tet2 mutations can outcompete (i.e. replicate more, make more white blood cells) than those without (5/n)

We investigated whether Tet2 mutant stem cells could outcompete others in the presence of the inflammatory cytokine TNF, which increases with age. We put a mix of normal and Tet2-/- stem cells into old mice that had lots of TNF and those with none (TNF KO). 6/n

Stem cells with Tet2 mutations could outcompete normal cells in old mice that had lots of TNF but not in TNF knockout mice. The aging inflammatory microenvironment contributes to CHIP! (7/n)

Cool finding- People with newly diagnosed #rheumatoidarthritis have lots of TNF and had low level of Tet2 and other CHIP mutants that went down as they started anti-TNF or anti-inflammatory therapy! Proof this happens in humans too (8/n)

Huge thank you to not on Bluesky Drs Michael Rauh (Queens), Candice Quin ( @uniofaberdeen.bsky.social ), Maggie Larche (UCalgary), Salman Basrai&Sagi Abelson @oicr.bsky.social and team. (9/9)

Publication: Neutrophil-mediated innate immune resistance to bacterial pneumonia is dependent on Tet2 function

https://bsky.app/profile/msmacrophage.bsky.social/post/3kubwknbcts2e
Click here for the full thread from Bluesky highlighting the major findings of the paper.
To see the full paper click here:
To see the commentary click here:



Bluesky thread:

Let me tell you about the #BowdishLab & friend’s most recent paper “Neutrophil-mediated innate immune resistance to bacterial pneumonia is dependent on Tet2 function”, led by Dr. C. Quin (now at @uniofaberdeen.bsky.social) @jclinical-invest.bsky.social https://www.jci.org/articles/view/171002
Tet2 is gene that is involved with methylating genes and therefore changing gene expression. Sometimes spontaneous mutations of Tet2 in hematopoetic stem cells (HSC) occur. These mutants tend to produce more myeloid cells (monocytes/neutrophils).
These myeloid producing HSCs tend to be more fit in the aging bone marrow (Darwinian survival of the fittest) and overtime, more and more of your myeloid cells are made from these Tet2 mutant clones.
In extreme cases this can lead to myelodysplastic disorders or cancer, but sub-clinical CHIP or clonal hematopoeisis of indeterminant potential occurs in many older adults.
People with CHIP (i.e., too many of their myeloid cells are made from Tet2 mutant progenitors) are prone to all sorts of conditions (e.g., heart disease) and pneumonia. We hypothesized that pneumonia risk might be due to changes in innate immune/myeloid cell function.
Mice defective in Tet2 did very poorly during Streptococcus pneumoniae infection (the most common cause of community acquired pneumonia in older adults), because their neutrophils were less able to kill bacteria.
We are excited about this @jclinical-invest.bsky.social publication because it is the first mechanistic explanation for the increased risk of pneumonia in CHIP. Generally CHIP is thought to affect macrophage function, but it clearly affects neutrophil gene expression & function as well.
Many thanks to Dr. Elsa Bou Ghahem for her most excellent Commentary https://www.jci.org/articles/view/181064 and for the great editorial & reviewer experience @jclinical-invest.bsky.social
Research Team:Candice Quin, Erica N. DeJong, Elina K. Cook, Yi Zhen Luo, Caitlyn Vlasschaert, Sanathan Sadh, Amy J.M. McNaughton, Marco M. Buttigieg, Jessica A. Breznik, Allison E. Kennedy, Kevin Zhao, Jeffrey Mewburn, Kimberly J. Dunham-Snary, Charles C.T. Hindmarch, Alexander G. Bick, Stephen L. Archer, Michael J. Rauh, Dawn M.E. Bowdish

Publication: “Immunomodulatory drugs have divergent effects on humoral and cellular immune responses to SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in people living with rheumatoid arthritis”

Jenna Benoit (PhD candidate) has published her first, first author paper characterizing how immune responses to vaccination differ in people living with rheumatoid arthritis. We found some interesting new drug-immune interactions.

See the full paper here.

See thread here: https://bsky.app/profile/msmacrophage.bsky.social/post/3kh2uswvqtm2u

or below….

New paper alert! @jennabenoit.bsky.social and team studied COVID-19 vaccinations in people living with rheumatoid arthritis who are on immunosuppressive drugs and found some interesting, and to our knowledge, unknown effects of specific drugs 1/n

Almost all studies of vaccine immunogenicity (i.e., how strong an immune response is to a vaccine) focus on antibody responses. Measuring the amount of antibodies produced is cheap and (relatively) easy; however, in the Omicron-era these are less predictive of protection than you might think 2/n

When investigating anti-receptor binding domain (RBD) antibodies @jennabenoit.bsky.social and team found that -unsurprisingly- people living with RA and men had lower antibody responses (men have lower antibody responses to vaccination in general), and people with COVID had higher responses (i.e., that hybrid immunity you’ve heard so much about) 3/n

What caused these lower antibody responses? DMARDs (disease modifying anti-rheumatic drugs),and anti-TNF were not associated with lower antibody levels, the effect of steroids was not significant, but costimulation inhibitors reduced antibody levels 4/n

Important caveat: The effect of co-stimulation inhibitors was about the same as being a biologic male, so whether this reduction is associated with increased risk of infection or not is not something we can comment on 5/n.

We didn’t see an effect of drugs on neutralizing antibodies (i.e., antibodies that bind the virus really well and prevent it from entering us), but we did not have enough people on some of the drugs to really investigate this 6/n.

My favourite part: CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses to vaccination are much, much harder to measure (each dot on the graph costs about $350 and 3+ hrs of time – hence the ‘team’ I keep mentioning) but we know that they are important for preventing infection.7/n

We found that people living with RA had lower CD4+ T cell responses (= ‘helper’ cells that support many aspects of the immune response to infection & vaccination), those who had had COVID were higher – more of that hybrid immunity you’ve heard about. 8/n

BUT even though we had a small number of people on JAK inhibitors, those who were on them had markedly lower CD4+ responses. The effect of co-stimulation inhibitors was not as apparent – but again low numbers of participants so hard to say. 9/n

Speculative side note: We use influenza vaccine as a control. Everyone has had exposure as kids so this measures a memory response made prior to having been vaccinated. Co-stim inhibitors don’t affect influenza but JAK inhibitors do – therefore no defect in pre-drug immune responses? 10/n

CD8+ T cell responses (‘killers’ of virus infected cells), were higher in men (previously known), and didn’t seem to be lower in most drugs, except maybe steroids. 11/n

Caveats: Our study was small and due to the fact we were measuring 1,2,3 doses, we were recruiting fast and furious and didn’t capture as many people on some of the drugs as we would have liked,so all results need to be replicated. 12/n

Clinical relevance: Some of these drugs are associated with increased risk of severe disease (see text for references) and by learning which aspects of the immune response they affect, we learn which aspects of the immune response are required for a successful vaccine. 13/n

Deepest appreciation for our research participants, the Canadian Arthritis Patient Alliance (see website for talks on this topic), the SUCCEED investigator team, our technical staff, fundign from the Public Health Agency of Canada, and you for reading to 14/n

Dr. Jessica Breznik talks about her research in the American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology Podcast

In this podcast first author Dr. Jessica A. Breznik of McMaster University, discusses the recently published manuscript titled “Diet-induced obesity alters intestinal monocyte-derived and tissue-resident macrophages and increases intestinal permeability in female mice independent of tumor necrosis factor.” 

NEW & NOTEWORTHY We found that diet-induced obesity in female mice has tissue- and time-dependent effects on intestinal paracellular permeability as well as monocyte-derived and tissue-resident macrophage numbers, surface marker phenotype, and intracellular production of the cytokines IL-10 and TNF. These changes were not mediated by TNF.

Article Citation: Diet-induced obesity alters intestinal monocyte-derived and tissue-resident macrophages and increases intestinal permeability in female mice independent of tumor necrosis factorJessica A. Breznik, Jennifer Jury, Elena F. Verdú, Deborah M. Sloboda, and Dawn M. E. Bowdish

American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology 2023 324:4, G305-G321

Bowdish lab research on the evolution of MARCO featured in the New York Times

Our research on the scavenger receptor MARCO was featured in an article “Air Pollution, Evolution, and the Fate of Billions of Humans” by Carl Zimmer in the New York Times. In this manuscript we collaborated with Dr. Brian Golding, an expert in evolutionary biology in order to understand the evolution of this macrophage receptor. MARCO (or macrophage receptor with collagenous structure) is expressed on macrophages where it binds bacteria and particles such as those found in dust and air pollution. We had hypothesized that because it is the receptor for two pathogens, Streptococcus pneumoniae and Mycobacterium tuberculosis, that have played a major part in driving human evolution, that we might find evidence of areas of the receptor that were undergoing rapid evolution to protect us from this pathogen.

In order to determine which regions of the protein were changing we performed a phylogenetic analysis of the sequence of MARCO from humans, our close ancestors, the Denisovians and Neanderthals, and primates. We found a few interesting things. There was one mutation, which we call F282S (282 refers to the 282nd amino acid in the protein, the F = phenylalanine and the S= serine), had changed very rapidly. All our primate, Denisovian and Neanderthal relatives had a serine residue in that position but fully 83% of the human genomes we analyzed had a phenylalanine. The fact that this mutation spread so quickly through the population means that there must have been very strong selection pressure. We cloned both variants and found that the human specific variant was indeed better at binding inert particles and bacteria. There were a few other interesting mutations we characterized (see article below) but the take home message is that some of the evolutionary adaptations we have made to deal with pathogens may have influenced our ability to handle air pollution or, since the savannah was predicted to be a dry and dusty place, the adaptations we’ve made to deal with particulates in the air may have changed our response to pathogens.

To read the full article, see below.

Human-specific mutations and positively-selected sites in MARCO confer functional changes. Novakowski KE, Yap NVL, Yin C, Sakamoto K, Heit B, Golding GB, Bowdish DME. Mol Biol Evol. 2017 Nov 20. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msx298.
PMID: 2916561

Publication: Age-associated Inflammation alters the aging trajectory.

This article is written for lay/broad audiences and describes what age-associated inflammation is and why it may be key to healthy/unhealthy aging.

White paper: “Paving The Way For Immunization Innovation” with the Lung Association Ontario